Old house closets

truegrid said:

Frances, love it, it is creating the thought for me to have someone come in and see if any ability to merge two separate closets into one continuous closest, and possibly build it out a little if needed. This might be a solution for closet space creation for the other 2 rooms as well. Has anyone ever just widen/lengthen the opening of their closets to get full access - how much that might cost? @grahamb sounds similar to what you are looking at doing, please share anything you learn


We did this in two rooms. In the master bedroom when we converted the side by side his and hers into a single closet, and the two separate doors were removed, a double door was installed. In our son's bedroom, the closet is of decent size but the single door made it hard to get to parts of it so we also installed a double door. It is much more usable now. it should not be that costly to do. We did it as part of a project but it really only required to cut the opening, and frame the new door jam and install the door. A handyman could probably do it in a day or two.

...but we still have beautiful old moldings around our closet doors. I hate to think about losing those! Form over function, I guess. Sigh.

BTW, if you like Elfa but don't have the budget for it, check out Rubbermaid Configurations. The initial closet set up is about $100 bucks and it will allow you to reconfigure a closet very easily. Once you hang the vertical supports, you can then move shelves around at any time. They also sell accessories like drawers and baskets if you need them. I have used it at my condo in JC as well as our house in Maplewood to turn even a very small closet into a much more useful space. All the components are metal. You can easily cut them with a handheld metal saw. I did it on my own at the condo in JC years ago. The saw cost me $10 at HD and with a little muscle I ended up turning a single shelf/rod closet into a fabulous space that held so much more. In our master bedroom, while I was using the main closet I had a configuration that worked for me, where I had hanging space for Shirts, Skirts (top/bottom) and dresses. Now that DH has taken over that closet we rearrange the configuration to have a single long hanging area for shirts and suits and much more shelving since he folds a lot more clothes. The change took about 5 minutes. And if we change our mind it is easy to do once again. These are the photos of the two configurations.

TarheelsInNj said:

...but we still have beautiful old moldings around our closet doors. I hate to think about losing those! Form over function, I guess. Sigh.


Yes that is to be considered. Can they be replicated? If you are turning two doors into one, you may have enough moldings for the double doors. They will need to be removed very carefully though. You also have to consider if you can find a matching door. Our house is circa 1950 and it lacks those 'old' characteristics. So it was rather easy to get stuff replaced.

We don't really have a spot to turn two doors into one (just one closet in each bedroom) so it would be more the issue of widening the door. My closet does have that black hole to the left that's hard to reach. A good candidate for shelving there, actually!

^ Even after widening the door...

Design tip: (this is from the design standards I learned from the closet company). It's much harder to access shelves tucked behind hanging, if the door doesn't open wide enough, you will not really be able to utilize/access the shelving and it will become a black hole. If it (the depth of storage space behind the return walls) is deep enough (24 inches) you would want to have hanging there because you can slide the contents to access, and shelving (which is shallower, only 12-14 inches for the most part) should be in the middle, where it's easier to access what's to the left and right.

Some great ideas here. We only have one closet in our master bedroom, and it's a relatively decent size by old house standards (not wide but somewhat deep). I use that closet. My husband's office is on the other side of our master bath - jack and jill set-up - and while it doesn't have a real closet he has a dresser and armoire in there that together hold most of his clothes. This arrangement works well for us because my husband usually gets up at an ungodly hour with a 5 in front of it, and he can get dressed in the other room without disturbing me. We both store out-of-season clothes in other closets around the house.

@muppet we used to have a very similar arrangement. Then we had another baby and it messed up the whole plan oh oh

Somehow my husband got the "walk-in" closet in our bedroom (it's narrow but relatively deep and has rods and shelves on both sides, so you could actually walk into it -- except for all his shoes taking up all the floor space). My closet is longish but shallow, and very full, and has only a single door, and it's very difficult to access items at the far end. Someday, after I get bookshelves built in my living room, I'll move the contents of the bookcase that stands in front of the closet wall -- and get rid of the bookcase -- and then break open that wall and make a double door there -- someday...

Edited to note that my house doesn't really qualify as an "old" house, it was built around 1950, so I'm always surprised that our closet space wasn't more generously allocated -- maybe that didn't become a priority until even later in the century...

We had one of those long narrow closets in our West Orange house, and I think the best thing we ever did for that house was break open the wall and double the width of the opening to access that space. I have no idea what they builder was thinking when he put up that room and left a 2.5-foot opening for a 6-foot-long closet. Crazy people.

I've always been closet obsessed. I think because I was traumatized by not enough closet space in my shared bedroom growing up.

In our first apartment, a brownstone, I actually suggested my landlord build an L shaped wall to create a walk in closet in our bedroom. Somehow they did it, and we hung all those Home Depot type wire racks on the wall and stuffed the entire thing to the ceiling,

In our maplewood house, where there was one tiny closet in the room we used as the master, the first project we did was frame out a closet the entire width of the room (from the door over), matched the trim as best we could and added double bi fold doors. Considering the barely three foot/shallow closet that was there, the extra 10 feet of storage was huge.

I can't even tell you what I've done in this house and one of the reasons I bought this house was because there were tons of closets in the master and two walk in closets on the third floor. We've redone every closet. Now I'm working on getting rid of anything that doesn't fit in a closet, and even emptying some of them. (Because I know when we move in however many years, it's going to be to a smaller place, and I don't want my life to be over run with my stuff!)

Thanks everyone, this was really helpful to hear how you approached the closet issues. This might start to move up to closer to the top of the list of to dos at our house. I am going to decide if we really need the moulding trim around the closet doors to match, or since its likely to be bifold or some other door(sliding appeals to me) break tradition. I have been told can replicate the trim if needed.

I looked up this thread because I have a tricky bedroom closet problem to solve... built-in shelving on one side, and a crawl space access door on the other (which we do need to frequently access since we have no attic), with closet bars hanging directly in front of them on both sides... and now one of the bars has fallen down (no idea why, we didn't have heavy stuff hanging from it).

@shh I have sent you a PM...


I'm glad you did... because I've now moved on to venting about our bedroom closet to venting about my son's closet. Ours are still a problem too, I just don't know what to do about any of it!

My son's room is small, so I hate the thought of taking up space with a dresser with the closet space is otherwise largely unused. We have a wire drawer contraption in there now but it's not all that practical. I feel certain a custom-built solution would be able to help that with real drawers and stuff though.


Maybe take an idea from college dorms: the beds in my son's dorm room last year were pretty high, which made room to put two decent-size two-drawer thingies underneath. Maybe there are cheaper versions, too, of those Pottery Barn-style beds that have lots of built-in storage.

I'm also still a big proponent of easyclosets.com. I don't know what we would do in my kids' smallish rooms without those built-in shelves.


zucca said:
Maybe take an idea from college dorms: the beds in my son's dorm room last year were pretty high, which made room to put two decent-size two-drawer thingies underneath. Maybe there are cheaper versions, too, of those Pottery Barn-style beds that have lots of built-in storage.
I'm also still a big proponent of easyclosets.com. I don't know what we would do in my kids' smallish rooms without those built-in shelves.

I'll check out easyclosets.com, thanks!

My son's bed is actually lofted already, with a "library" underneath which he loves. That helps free up the floor space a bookcase would take up, at least!


My daughter already has a platform bed with drawers underneath; they really do come in handy.

Our house is too small to just write off her closet... have to see how we can make it more useful (and of course get that fallen bar fixed too).


If you do the easyclosets thing, make sure you get the okay for your design from one of their consultants before you buy. I don't remember exactly how it worked, but mainly you tell them the measurements of your closet and have them review what you've picked out to do online. As long as you have their okay, then if it doesn't fit or work for some reason, it's on them instead of on you. Not sure whether that is still the way it works, since it's been a long time now. I do see on the website that they will also design the space for you for no fee, or consult with you on what you designed to look for improvements. Also, I had a problem with a drawer front long after we bought the closet inserts, and they shipped me another one for free no questions asked.


blue pool I responded to your message.


shh, do you have a website? I need help too!


Minimal blog, at best, but message me and we can connect!


In order to add a comment – you must Join this community – Click here to do so.